How to Measure Ingredients for Baking

9

This post may contain affiliate links | disclosure policy

How you measure your ingredients could be the reason for inconsistent results. It can make all the difference between a delicate, fluffy cake and a tough one. Could you be doing this without realizing it?

How to measure ingredients when following baking recipe instructions.

Think about the last time you made a baking recipe that didn’t turn out as the author promised. Was it a different brand of ingredients, or did the author oversell the recipe? There’s another factor worth checking: how you measure ingredients for baking. Measuring is the most foundational step in any recipe, but it’s often overlooked because it comes first.

The short version: For the most accurate results, weigh dry ingredients like flour and sugar on a kitchen scale. If you’re using cups, dip and sweep dry ingredients, pack brown sugar firmly, measure liquids in a clear liquid measuring cup at eye level, and use measuring spoons for small amounts.

Which Tool to Use for Each Ingredient

IngredientBest way to measure
Flour and powdered sugarKitchen scale, or a dry measuring cup: dip and sweep
Granulated sugar, cornmeal, chocolate chipsDry measuring cup: scoop and sweep level
Brown sugarDry measuring cup, packed firmly, or a kitchen scale
Milk, cream, water, and oilLiquid measuring cup on a flat surface, read at eye level
Honey and maple syrupLiquid measuring cup sprayed with cooking spray
Sour cream, peanut butter, applesauceDry measuring cup, filled and leveled with a spatula
ButterMarks on the stick wrapper, or a kitchen scale
Baking powder, baking soda, salt, spices, and extractsMeasuring spoons, leveled off
Cooking Methods Cheat Sheet
Get my free 2-page cheat sheet: all 16 cooking methods, the temperatures that matter, and the science behind each one. New here? You’ll also get my free 5-day email course and my weekly recipes. Unsubscribe anytime.

Why Accurate Measuring Matters in Baking

Baking is all about chemistry. A certain ratio of ingredients is needed for the right chemical reactions to happen. Too few eggs, for example, means not enough protein for the Maillard reaction to turn your cake a nice golden brown.

Recipes are tested, so measuring correctly means you’re making the recipe the way the author intended. Using the proper technique also gives you a consistent result every time you bake, so you don’t have to wonder why your signature cake fell flat this time.

Weight vs. Volume

There are two ways to measure ingredients: by volume or by weight. Measuring cups and spoons measure volume, while a kitchen scale measures weight. Not all recipes are created equal. Some call only for cups and some only for grams, which is why, as a recipe developer, I include both measurements in my recipes whenever I can.

Measuring flour by weight on a scale and by volume in a cup.

Which Is More Accurate?

Measuring cups are convenient but trickier, because the volume depends on how an ingredient fills the space. Several types of flour aerate easily or compact with pressure, so they fill the cup differently depending on how you pack it. That means you could add more or less than the recipe calls for.

On a scale, you can be sure to measure 100 grams accurately every time. Measuring by weight is best for accuracy and reproducibility. I often use both, checking the weight on a scale after I measure by volume.

How to Measure Dry Ingredients

Measuring cups with various ingredients inside.

Dry Measuring Cups

Dry measuring cups usually come in ¼ cup, ⅓ cup, ½ cup, and 1 cup sizes. The general rule for dry ingredients is to scoop, then sweep off the excess with a straight-edge spatula or the flat side of a knife so the top is level. This works perfectly for ingredients like cornmeal, granulated sugar, chocolate chips, and cranberries.

Measuring Spoons

Measuring spoons are best for small amounts of ingredients like vanilla extract, spices, and baking powder and baking soda. They usually range from ⅛ teaspoon to 1 tablespoon. Use them the same way as a dry measuring cup: fill, then level off the top.

Flour and Other Compressible Ingredients

Flour and powdered sugar are tricky because they compress. Use one of these methods:

  • Dip and sweep: Lightly dip the measuring cup into the bag, then sweep away the excess with a straight-edge spatula or the flat side of a knife. Don’t press down as you dip, or the flour will pack.
  • Spoon and sweep: Spoon the flour into the cup instead of scooping with the cup, lightly dusting it in. Then sweep away the excess to level it.

The method you choose changes how much flour ends up in the cup:

Diagram comparing two ways to measure a cup of flour: dip and sweep weighs 142 grams and spoon and sweep weighs 120 grams, a 22-gram difference of about 2½ tablespoons.

That 22-gram (about ¾ ounce) difference is about 2½ tablespoons of flour per cup, which can noticeably change the texture of a cake or cookie. I use the dip-and-sweep method, and my recipes list 142 grams for 1 cup of all-purpose flour. For more ingredient weights, see the cups to grams chart in my kitchen scale guide.

Brown Sugar

Measuring brown sugar and packing it into the cup.

Brown sugar contains molasses and moisture, so its granules are uneven and sticky and don’t settle evenly in the cup. Packing softened brown sugar into the cup removes the air pockets, so you measure sugar, not air.

Press it in with just enough force that it no longer compresses easily and comes out holding the shape of the cup. Try to use the same pressure every time. For this tricky ingredient, a scale is worth it.

How to Measure Liquid Ingredients

Liquid Measuring Cups

For liquids like milk, cream, and cooking oil, a liquid measuring cup is the easiest tool. You could fill a dry measuring cup to the brim, but it’s hard to get it into the bowl without spilling.

A liquid measuring cup’s top line sits well below the rim, so nothing sloshes out. Set the cup on a flat surface and read the meniscus (the curve at the top of the liquid) at eye level. Looking down from above makes it look like there’s more liquid than there is, so you’ll add too little.

Sticky Ingredients

Thick, sticky liquids like honey and maple syrup cling to the cup. Spray the cup with cooking spray first, and they’ll pour right out.

How to Measure Semi-Liquids and Butter

Measuring sour cream in a cup and scraping off the excess.

Semi-liquid ingredients like peanut butter, applesauce, and sour cream are measured in a dry measuring cup: fill it well, then level the top with a spatula or knife. Soft butter and shortening can be measured the same way.

Butter and shortening sticks are even easier, since the wrappers are marked in tablespoons and cups. These aren’t common outside the United States, though. In many other countries, like New Zealand, Australia, and the United Kingdom, butter is usually sold in 250-gram or 500-gram blocks, so weighing it is easiest.

Using a Kitchen Scale

Measuring chocolate chips inside a glass bowl on top of a kitchen scale.

A scale takes the guesswork out of measuring, since you don’t have to worry about how an ingredient fills a cup. You can weigh almost anything, and you can switch between units. To measure correctly, set an empty bowl on the scale and press tare (or zero) before adding the ingredient.

A scale also makes it easy to scale a recipe up or down, since you’re not limited by the sizes of your measuring cups. It’s less helpful for tiny amounts of baking powder, baking soda, or salt. One-eighth teaspoon of baking powder weighs about 0.5 grams, and most kitchen scales round to the nearest gram, so you could end up adding twice as much. Use measuring spoons for those.

A kitchen scale is a worthy investment, especially if you love to bake, but measuring cups and spoons are still convenient. It never hurts to have all the tools, as long as you use them correctly! For tips on choosing and using one, plus a cups to grams chart, see my digital kitchen scale guide.

My Measuring Tools

  • Measuring cups and spoons: I use OXO measuring cups and spoons (affiliate link). Their magnetic handles keep them together for storage.
  • Kitchen scale: My OXO kitchen scale (affiliate link) has a pull-out display, so a large bowl or plate doesn’t hide the numbers.
  • Liquid measuring cup: Look for a clear cup with easy-to-read markings and a top line that sits well below the rim.

Find all of my favorite kitchen tools on my Shop page.

Tips to Remember

  • Read the wording closely: Does the recipe say “sifted” or “packed lightly”? These words change how much ends up in the cup.
  • Notice the order: “1 cup sifted flour” is different from “1 cup flour, sifted.” For the first, sift before measuring. Sifted flour has more air, so 1 cup of sifted flour weighs less than 1 cup of flour sifted afterward.
  • Melted vs. solid butter: Melted and solid butter have different structures and densities, so ½ cup of solid butter weighs differently from ½ cup of melted butter.
  • Stir flour before measuring: Flour settles in the bag over time, so mix it gently before scooping. Once the cup is filled, don’t shake or tap it, which forces the air out and packs it down.

Need to convert a recipe? See my kitchen conversion chart. Baking at a high elevation? Here’s my guide to high altitude baking.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it better to measure ingredients by weight or volume?

By weight. A kitchen scale measures the same amount every time, no matter how an ingredient is packed into the cup. Measuring cups are convenient, but flour and brown sugar can fill a cup differently each time.

How do you measure brown sugar?

Pack it firmly into a dry measuring cup until it no longer compresses easily and holds the shape of the cup when you turn it out. Packing removes air pockets, so you measure sugar instead of air.

How do you measure sour cream?

Spoon sour cream into a dry measuring cup, fill it well, and level the top with a spatula or knife. The same method works for peanut butter, applesauce, and soft butter.

How do you measure spices?

Use measuring spoons. Fill the spoon, then level off the top with a straight edge, just like a dry measuring cup.

How do you measure milk or cream?

Use a clear liquid measuring cup on a flat surface and read the line at eye level. Looking from above makes it seem like there’s more liquid than there is.

How do you measure honey without it sticking?

Spray the measuring cup with cooking spray before adding the honey or maple syrup, and it will pour right out.

More Baking Basics

Jessica Gavin

I’m Jessica, a Certified Food Scientist and Certified Culinary Scientist, cookbook author of Easy Culinary Science for Better Cooking, and culinary school graduate with a food science degree from Cal Poly San Luis Obispo. I share recipes along with the science behind them to help you cook with confidence.

Thanksgiving, Made Easy!
Get my free 3-day email guide to a stress-free Thanksgiving, plus my printable game plan.
Jessica Gavin standing in the kitchen

You May Also Like

Reader Interactions

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

9 Comments Leave a comment or review

  1. Paul Costanzo says

    Great recipes. Question is; when I mix spices and herbs (like chicken breasts). How do I know how much of each spice to add. ie.. garlic powder, paparika, etc…
    Thank you… Grandma Meatball and chicken breasts are in demand at my house. Thank you

    • Jessica Gavin says

      I have recipes on my website for chicken seasoning, tacos, etc. For salt and pepper I usually like to do a 2:1 ratio. Then I might add about 1/4 to 1/2 of the amount of garlic or onion powder compared to the salt as an accent flavor. Depending on how you cook the ingredient, paprika can burn. I start with adding in a small amount, about 1/4 of the salt, and increase to taste. It helps with enhancing the color.

  2. Steve says

    Should the flour used for dusting a work surface come from a recipe’s measured amount or is that “extra”? Similar question for any fat used to grease or oil a cooking surface.

  3. Mary says

    Is it accurate to measure liquids such as water and milk on a kitchen scale rather than using a measuring jug? I often find it confusing as Australia has different cup sizes to USA, which means when finding recipes online it can make big differences to the results.

    • Jessica Gavin says

      I think that measuring on a scale would make for more consistent measuring results for liquids. I totally see how the cups can be confusing as it varies in different countries.

  4. Judy says

    Thank you for this. There were several things I had not thought about before such as the shifted flour vs flour, sifted.

  5. catherine says

    Yes. All skilled people have all tools with them to complete a task. I use my scale and spoons when baking.